- Joined
- Jun 23, 2003
- Messages
- 7,191
- Solutions
- 10
- Reaction score
- 3,162
- Points
- 150
- Favorite Pinball Machine
- Jurassic Park
oh well, i finished the book. carlin really takes it to love at the end, albeit in a velvety-glove, damning-by-arched-eyebrow kind of way. but it's pretty clear he thinks mike is full of it. i'm with you on that one now, bill.
i noticed the author came up with the same point that i had made earlier-- if love and whoever else hadn't been so intolerant and full of themselves, brian probably would have made it through smile in 1967 without getting wrecked, and may well have continued further in that direction. we'll never know.
i think van dyke parks also deserves a lot of credit for those wonderful lyrics, too. love couldn't make head nor tail of them at the time and it made him belligerent. fast forward to modern times and he seems to own almost the exact same attitude-- the lyrics were 'too weird' and it was a 'fortunate thing that the plug got pulled on smile'... not to mention he seems completely oblivious to how much of a ruthless, litigious bully he became in the mid-60's and still is today, it seems like.
he completely missed and/or ignored the memo that "brian wilson IS the beach boys... the rest of us are just his messengers." --dennis in 1970
i also find it quite impressive that brian was able to work with so many other song-writers interchangeably. most often they did more of the lyrics and he wrote most of the music. but mike was one of his early collaborators, and almost certainly couldn't handle the fact that brian moved on artistically and in his partnerships. yet with the imperatives of murry and the nature of the family business, brian was also in no position to re-form the band as he did many years later, to glorious effect.
mike love clearly failed to grasp that brian was the far more talented musician. in fact, the book said that around the mid-60's brian was being all but heralded as the nation's top musician. professional musicians would apparently come in to work on a session, see this tall, baby-faced kid in charge... roll their eyes internally... and then get their mind blown by how inventive and ingenious the young dude was.
...
welp... not sure what there is left to say. this was the first book i read completely on tablet and it was quite fun for the most part. thanks for joining in the discussion, guys...!
so then... what's next?
i noticed the author came up with the same point that i had made earlier-- if love and whoever else hadn't been so intolerant and full of themselves, brian probably would have made it through smile in 1967 without getting wrecked, and may well have continued further in that direction. we'll never know.
i think van dyke parks also deserves a lot of credit for those wonderful lyrics, too. love couldn't make head nor tail of them at the time and it made him belligerent. fast forward to modern times and he seems to own almost the exact same attitude-- the lyrics were 'too weird' and it was a 'fortunate thing that the plug got pulled on smile'... not to mention he seems completely oblivious to how much of a ruthless, litigious bully he became in the mid-60's and still is today, it seems like.
he completely missed and/or ignored the memo that "brian wilson IS the beach boys... the rest of us are just his messengers." --dennis in 1970
i also find it quite impressive that brian was able to work with so many other song-writers interchangeably. most often they did more of the lyrics and he wrote most of the music. but mike was one of his early collaborators, and almost certainly couldn't handle the fact that brian moved on artistically and in his partnerships. yet with the imperatives of murry and the nature of the family business, brian was also in no position to re-form the band as he did many years later, to glorious effect.
mike love clearly failed to grasp that brian was the far more talented musician. in fact, the book said that around the mid-60's brian was being all but heralded as the nation's top musician. professional musicians would apparently come in to work on a session, see this tall, baby-faced kid in charge... roll their eyes internally... and then get their mind blown by how inventive and ingenious the young dude was.
...
welp... not sure what there is left to say. this was the first book i read completely on tablet and it was quite fun for the most part. thanks for joining in the discussion, guys...!
so then... what's next?