When I saw
this list of the top 100 Sherlock Holmes performances of all time, I was instantly piqued.
Side note: not sure how many people know this, but there were dozens & dozens and actors who played the role long before Basil Rathbone came along and portrayed him in the 40's.
Now I'm seeing some real interesting contenders in the ~top ten, such as Jonny Lee Miller in
Elementary (2012-2019), Christopher Plummer in
Murder by Decree (1979), and the Russian-made films of Vasily Livanov, i.e.
The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes and Dr. Watson (1980-1987).
But one that especially intrigues me is Yūko Takeuchi in
Miss Sherlock (2018 ).
--from the article:--
"
HBO Asia’s Miss Sherlock, which is one of the best Holmesian adaptations I’ve ever seen, is a modern, female, Japanese reboot of the famous detective partnership. But those more obvious reasons don’t solely account for why the show is so vanguard and engaging.
It’s star, Yûko Takeuchi, is riveting as “Sherlock,” an elegant, if aloof and snide, young woman who uses her brilliant observational powers to solve crimes, mostly for her own amusement. She is bossy, self-directed, cranky, and whiny. But she is also glamorous! She loves designer clothes and always looks eminently cool hiking over to a crime scene in her long dusters and stilettos.
It’s nice to see a Holmes who clearly loves being the center of attention, so much. Her relationship with Shihori Kanjiya’s "Wato" (the Watson character) is also compelling; Sherlock acts like the spoiled, rich-girl roommate archetype we’ve seen so often, a catty older sister-figure to the shy and sensitive Wato. Though a friendship does grow out of their incidental situationship, Sherlock still gives Wato an extremely hard time. The whole vibe just totally works, and you’ll be thinking about Yūko Takeuchi’s performance long after you’re done with the eight episodes."
.
Although I admit I'm interesting in those other productions, I'm definitely going to watch this series. Not unlike how there was no way I could pass on the Benadryl Cumberbund (sp) series, once I heard about it. This one is eight episodes of 48-min each, perfect for me.
.
Sadly, and rather unbelievably, I've already learned that Ms. Takeuchi commit suicide only two years after series one, and only one year after getting married.
Somehow it reminds me of another one of my favorite Japanese film-people, Juzo Itami, who directed the brilliant
Tampopo and
A Taxing Woman, who was forced by the Yakuza to leap to his death in 1997, after making a film which heavily mocked the Yakuza institution (
Minbo: the Gentle Art of Japanese Extortion).
So I don't know quite what to think about all this, but I have a feeling that as much as I might enjoy this new series, it's also going to leave me pretty damn glum.
Damn, I'm still gonna watch it, though!