A little history, this goes back to the very beginning of Pinball Nirvana and was then named The Magic of Flipperless (over 18 years ago), my older brother found the chick and knew how to add a pinball under her, the current logo was created by shiva.
It still seems awesome to me all of these years later but with technology these days could probably be better.
Here's a thread about logo ideas from 2006 that I'm currently trying to fix the links to, but the excellent attachments still seem to work:
Edited 1/19/06, Started Poll and added the following: We have had quite a few excellent ideas submitted for a new site logo! Just wanted to get an idea of what you folks like, see this page and vote for the existing logo or the logo number. Wondering if anyone would like to submit new logo...